In my recent email to the members of the Fredericksburg Writers Conference, I said, "If you aren't in a writing critique group, you probably aren't a very good writer."
Member Jack Swanzy objected, quoting an article in the New York Times (I think
this is it, but I'm not sure, let me know if not). Jack said (reprinted with his permission):
I am intrigued by your insistence on participation in a writing critique group. Especially the notion that “if you aren’t in a … group, you’re probably not a very good writer.” There are too many examples of great writers who weren’t. And too many examples of people in groups whose writing falls very far short.
The following is from an essay in the NY Times today. Writing critique group? How passé. You really need an MFA.
“That’s not necessarily a negative notion (we are all MFA’s), according to Dr. McGurl and Mr. Harbach (who received a $650,000 advance for his first novel, “The Art of Fielding”). But it seems to trouble many others, especially aspiring novelists and poets. With so many highly tutored creative writers already out there, is success possible without the instruction and literary connections that are cultivated in M.F.A. programs and that a volatile publishing industry — now evolved around program graduates and sensibilities — has come to look for and expect?"
In defense I consider my own participation for more than ten years in a critique group; I have done a good deal of writing which I thought was brilliant, but when read in front of the group appeared less so. The simple process of reading your work in front of other writers is all by itself instructive, and the heart-felt, sometimes harsh, always thoughtful critiques more so. Our Conference speaker from a couple of years ago, the delightful local author Anointette Van Heugten, detailed her long journey to becoming a best selling writer, and she didn't mention being in a writing critique group. However - she did explain a close relationship with her New York agent, who critiqued her story every step of the way, and I would say that is a critique group.
What is your experience? Lets hear about it.